Web log site feed    
01 August 2007
MCUSA - audacious or just nervous?
young adult leadership is still not being adequately cultivated for the next generation.
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
07 July 2007
Living the call after convention
I really want to try and take what I've seen and heard here at convention and put it to use once I get home, and things I'd like to suggest to folks back at Landisville, too. Here's a handful:
Need a quilt? A quilt made at San Jose out of fabrics from around the world is being auctioned off on eBay right now. Proceeds will benefit the capitol campaign at First Mennonite Church of San Francisco, which will be used to purchase the building occupied by the San Francisco Mennonite Voluntary Service unit. First Mennonite holds this MVS unit as such a central priority for their mission that they're working to buy the MVS house before they buy themselves a permanent meeting space. Bidding closes at 3:00 pm on Monday, 9 June; it's currently up to $2760.
God's love has no borders. Especially after watching the documentary Fuerza, I'm convinced that one of the best ways Mennonites can put peace into practice right now is to work for just immigration policy, and reach out to immigrants already here, regardless of their legal status.
An easy first step is to write to Congress; one of the most saddening things I've heard on this subject is that Senators and Representatives report receiving 300 hateful, anti-immigrant letters for every one letter calling for justice and mercy. The House and Senate websites have the necessary contact information. Resources for letter writing are at the MCUSA and MCC websites. If you've written before, write again.
Over the longer term, welcoming immigrants takes work. One of my table-mates at the Delegate Assembly was a pastor at a congregation with both Anglo and Hispanic members, and he told us that it's taken - and still takes - lots of thinking about the specific details of bilingual worship and deliberate inclusion to bring the two groups together. One way to start the process, which I'm going to try in this next year, is to learn Spanish.
Health care access. Expect to hear soon from the Executive Board about the health care access initiative we approved this week. The program development process is going to ultimately hinge on individual congregations' input and support.
Young adult involvement. As the statement I posted earlier probably makes more than clear, there's a lot going on here. What may be equally obvious is that it's not necessarily well defined where things are going. Are we looking at the eventual development of a Young Adult Caucus or similar sub-group at conference or within the Delegate Assembly? Will we just continue focusing on intentionally reaching out to young adults and involving them in leadership processes? I have to say, I've personally felt very supported by Landisville, and I've deeply appreciated the chance to act as a delegate this week. Again, the BikeMovement documentary will be coming in September - have a look and join the conversation.
Labels: church, San Jose 2007, service
06 July 2007
It's over!
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
Young adult statement
Young adults have been called the future of the church. We come before you today to say that the future has already begun.
We come from varied walks of life. Some of us went to Mennonite colleges, some of us did not. Some of us are connected to our home congregations, and others are finding it hard to connect to any congregation. We have built relationships that transcend geography. We are using the new medium of the Internet – including sites like the Young Anabaptist Radicals blog and the Anabaptist Network on Facebook – as forums for conversation, debate, and community. We are seekers in our faith and full of complex questions.
We have experienced a shift in the way the church listens for our voices. We have been offered space to converse with the church community. A clear example of this is the number of Young Adult delegates sitting on the floor today. As one young delegate said, “As soon as I open my mouth, the attention of the table is on what I have to say.” Space has been given here at San Jose for conversations with Executive Leadership. BikeMovement created opportunity for conversations with congregations and with conference leadership. Our request for space for our voices has been heard, and we thank you for hearing us.
Many of you have been participants in these conversations and have heard for yourself our questions and comments. The nature of our diversity does not lend itself to a unified voice. Many of the young adults participating in these conversations come from the context of a middle class, white, and Mennonite college-educated perspective. We lament the fact that it has been difficult to represent the true diversity of young people within the Mennonite church. In light of this acknowledgment, these are some of the themes we have heard:
1. We are thankful for the leadership we have been given and want more ways to get involved in the church, both in local congregations and at broader organizational levels.
2. We are grateful for the opportunities we have had to learn from the global Anabaptist movement and desire to share these experiences and relationships with those who have not had this privilege.
3. Social justice and a visible, active witness for peace are integral to our faith.
4. We desire the church community to be a place where we can grapple with complex questions, realities, and issues without preconceived outcomes.
5. We desire an attitude of openness and hospitality across age, race, gender, sexual orientation, and socio-economic status.
6. We struggle with the tension between opportunities that take us outside our local congregations and our desire for continued connection and relationship with the church.
7. We seek community that deliberately includes those on the margins of the traditional Mennonite culture.
8. We want a church that practices its beliefs with consistency and integrity.
In response to our conversations, we challenge you, our delegates and your representative congregations, to:
- Continue to walk with us and mentor us as we work through questions that may be uncomfortable for you. They are often uncomfortable for us. Let's learn together.
- Continue to encourage us to take leadership roles; many of us yearn to be involved, but lack the courage to call ourselves forward. Help us recognize and utilize our God-given gifts and talents.
Let us use our skills and perspectives to help the church call our peers into fellowship.
In the listening that we have done, we acknowledge that young adults do not have a unified vision for the future of the church; this is a testament to the current state of the church. We sense that the Mennonite Church currently does not have a shared theological vision as many individuals, congregations, conferences, and organizations have varied definitions our shared Mennonite identity.
So we leave with you these questions: How do we live, worship, and continue to cultivate this community of believers in the midst of, or even in spite of, these differences? What shared practices will keep us in relationship with each other as we walk forward as a complex and ever-changing church community?
Labels: church, San Jose 2007, young adults
Health care and anti-racism
The Assembly worked on two major issues since I last blogged:
Anti-racism. We received a report on MCUSA's priority to be an anti-racist organization, and discussed ways that congregations could connect across racial/ethnic lines, and how the Executive Board could support that. Between this discussion and the documentary Fuerza, which I saw last evening, I've come away with a really strong sense that we need to be deliberate about reaching out beyond the historically white European Mennonite circle. I think I may have to make an effort to start learning Spanish, and I want to try and be creative about how I do that.
Health care access.We revisited the discussion of the health care access initiative, and things felt more positive this time. In open discussion, the Assembly asked the Executive Board for a lot of specifics: eligibility, cost, the necessary level of congregational participation across the church. But we also started to talk about ways that we can communicate the need for this action back home, and I think most delegates are going to return from San Jose with as advocates for the project. It also seems likely that the Executive Board is going to put some real effort into developing educational material to help explain the scope of the health care crisis, the importance of action as a church, and the cost of doing nothing.
After a little more talk about health care in this morning's session, we handed in our ballots - I think the resolution is likely to pass, authorizing the Executive Board to begin exploring the options.
Labels: church, health care, San Jose 2007
05 July 2007
Open dialog or shared identity?
Therefore, we call upon the leaders of Mennonite Church USA to discourage, and member conferences to end, the practice of disciplining or expelling congregations based on differing interpretations of the Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective.The question is, essentially, should area conferences have the ability to expel whole congregations when their members act or teach a stance that opposes the broader conference's understanding of the COF?
We opened the discussion with presentations for and against the statement, then had discussion at our tables. The argument for the resolution essentially was that (1) the COF was never intended as a prescriptive, binding creed, but as a description of shared Mennonite faith, (2) that disciplining whole congregations at the conference level (rather than individuals at the congregational level) creates "collateral damage", effectively disciplining people for going to church in a particular group, and (3) that expelling congregations at variance with the COF cuts off dialog, and is inconsistent with MCUSA's principles of Agreeing and Disagreeing in Love [PDF]. The argument against held that (1) it is entirely appropriate to use the COF as a guide to our shared Mennonite identity, and (2) that the power to expel congregations is both necessary to maintain that identity and duly granted to area conferences by MCUSA's bylaws [PDF].
Our table discussion failed to come to any conclusion (as might be expected), but the sense of the table I got is that we were torn between the need to somehow maintain Mennonite identity by disciplining around our shared beliefs, and our discomfort at the inherent ugliness and un-peacefulness of congregational expulsion. Broader-level discussion at an open-microphone time that followed showed that this was a pretty widespread tension.
Personally, I think the statement is a good thing, and should be considered for real action. My feeling, which I expressed in the table discussion, is that expulsion is a kind of weapon, and, like all weapons, people want to hang onto it primarily out of fear and distrust. And when I think about situations in which I might want a congregation to be expelled, I sense that my thinking is colored by fear. Letting go of weapons takes courage, in this case the courage to say, "I disagree with you, but the differences between our beliefs are not a threat to my faith." I think that ending the practice of expelling congregations would be a deeply courageous demonstration of peaceful living within the church.
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
Member profile 2006 report online
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
04 July 2007
On fire for the politics of Jesus
Boy, was I wrong. Paul Alexander (bio on the San Jose 2007 site; scroll down to Wednesday evening to find him) gave a profoundly powerful testimony about his rediscovery of Pentacostalism's roots as a peace church with the help of none other than John Howard Yoder and the MCC. In a message perfectly tuned for 4 July, he reminded us just how radical it is to defy the culture of nationalism in favor of allegiance to God's Kingdom. It was truly spiritually refreshing.
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
Healthcare Access?
- That, as a denomination, we are committed to providing basic health insurance for all eligible pastors, and
- That we request the Executive Board to oversee the development and implementation of a plan whereby all congregations of Mennonite Church USA participate together in an arrangement that covers all of our pastors with basic health insurance
In spite of this, the support for the resolution among the delegates seems mixed. The possible program models discussed will require the entire church to commit to providing health care for pastors. This could happen by developing a plan that every congregation would join without concern for getting the best market-available rate and benefits, to spread risk and cost as broadly as possible. This could also happen by developing a system in which congregations could choose to join the denominational plan or opt out, but would contribute to subsidize memberships for lower-income and smaller congregations. Either way, churches like Landisville, with lots of members and potentially their own ideas about what they want to do for their pastor's health needs, would have to sacrifice to help churches that presently don't have many options.
In open discussion (after discussion at our tables), most delegates expressed support for the broad principle that we should be willing, as a church, to sacrifice in these ways for the greater good. But many also questioned whether the commitment could be made. And that was frankly disheartening. If we, the church, don't have the will to come together for mutual aid, what hope is there for society at large? I pray we can work beyond this as the discussion continues.
Labels: church, health care, San Jose 2007
Images of San Jose
Labels: church, photo, San Jose 2007
03 July 2007
Down to business
Member Profile 2006. Conrad Kanagy presented key points from his 2006 demographic and opinion survey of Mennonites across the country. I'm not sure I feel good about the results, which seemed to show that the church is both shrinking and losing its commitment to its historic peace position. Apparently, more than a fifth of Mennonites say they would choose some form of military service if drafted, almost a quarter think that the U.S. invasion of Iraq was a good decision - and 14 percent of our households own handguns!
Apart from my personal objections to all these positions, I think this assimilation of Mennonite views into the American mainstream may exacerbate the problem of shrinking membership. If we lose our uniqueness, what good news do we have to bring to people that they can't get at the megachurch down the street?
There is one bright spot, though: as a group, people from non-European backgrounds are expanding their presence in the church, and nonwhite congregations are growing faster and show more commitment to outreach. Whatever else our future will be, it's going to be more diverse.
Christian Churches Together. We also discussed a proposal (to be voted on later in the week) to join Christian Churches Together, an ecumenical organization that spans the historic branches of the Church. It seems like a good group, and, based on my table's responses, it looks like we'll vote to join.
Apology to Native Americans. The Assembly unanimously passed a resolution in support of a U.S. Government apology to Native Americans for centuries of persecution, neglect, and mistreatment in the course of European settlement of the present-day United States. In the materials delegates received in connection with our resolution was a suggestion that everyone write their congressmen and senators to ask them to support the apology bill (designated S.J.RES.4 in the Senate, and H.J.RES.3 in the House), as a first step towards reconciliation.
Sustainability. Anita Amstutz and Luke Gascho presented some principles of environmentalism in an Anabaptist context for our discussion. This felt a little vague to me; it's certainly important to articulate a commitment to sustainability as a church, but I think it may be far more important to be thinking about specific policies we can implement towards those goals. (Just off the top of my head, MMA could begin promoting green design and architecture when it helps finance church building projects.) As it was, we didn't even vote on a resolution!
More tomorrow!
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
Agreeing and disagreeing in love
Yesterday evening's session was pure introduction; talking about the vision of MCUSA and the purpose of the Delegate Assembly, and about the roles of the various ministries of MCUSA. This morning's session focused on the practice of "Agreeing and Disagreeing in Love," which will inform just about every discussion we have as an Assembly.
The table had some good, and occasionally challenging, thoughts about conflict and the ways in which we Mennonites can practice peace among ourselves as we preach it to the world. We particularly focused on how our congregations and larger organizations deal with individuals and groups within the church who practice or preach differently, and on the interactions between discipline and discipling. It's a good lead-in to the statement for discussion that's on the agenda for later in the week, which addresses the practice of breaking fellowship with congregations who are considered to be at variance with the Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective. Looks like it could be an interesting week.
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
It was a good bike ...
Labels: biking, San Jose 2007, summer, travel
What I did on my summer vacation
Thursday, 21 June
Dave and I were supposed to leave the Willamette Valley bright and early this morning, after meeting in Portland, OR and spending the night at the home of Josh Miller, a mutual friend from EMU days. Then, getting into Portland on the 20th, I got a call from Dave - he'd had a flight delay break up his travel from Washington, DC to Portland, and he'd be a whole day late. Fortunately, Josh was good enough not only to put up with me for an extra night, but to show me around Portland all day, including its fantastic Japanese Garden. Dave didn't arrive till 0300 the next morning!Friday, 22 June
We slept in late (or I did; Dave had jetlag to work out) and Josh drove us down to the coast, cutting off the day's travel we no longer had time for. Leaving a bit after noon from Lincoln City, OR, we biked the first 71.7km (44.5mi) to Beachside State Park, where we spent the night. Good news: many Oregon (and California) state parks have campsites reserved for cyclists and hikers, available at a much lower rate.Saturday, 23 June
Our first full day: 123.0km (76.4mi) south on U.S. 101 to the Bluebill campground in Oregon Dunes National Recreation Area. The scenery was spectacular - we saw sea lions and Brandt's Cormorants at a series of caves along the coast. I was soon tired of being passed by the endless line of RV's that filled the highway, though. We met up with two girls who were also on a long ride, theirs from Seattle to San Francisco, and ended up splitting the more pricey U.S. Forest Service campsite with them.Sunday, 24 June
Kind of a rough start to the day; we woke up to the tail end of a light rain shower, and then, not three miles into the ride, my rear tire went flat. We made 122.5km (76.1mi) to Humbug Mountain State Park, where a dinner of fresh shrimp and scallops we found in the nearby town of Port Orford went a long way to making things better.Monday, 25 June
We made poorer progress today; while coasting down a hill a little north of Brookings, OR, I paid for abusing my brakes with a major blowout in my front tire. Till Dave hitchhiked to the nearest bike shop for a replacement tire and we got back on the road, we'd lost almost half a day. The sunset at Harris State Park, where we finished the 82.8km (51.4mi) ride, was pretty spectacular.Tuesday, 26 June
The day started cold and misty, and mostly stayed that way. We crossed the border into California early in the morning, and by early afternoon were off the 101 on a scenic alternative route through Redwood State/National Park. It's been more than a year since I'd last seen Sequoia sepervirens, and it was powerfully refreshing to coast through cool avenues of giant trees. We finished at Patrick's Point State Park, 134.4km (83.5mi) from our start.Wednesday, 27 June
From the start of the trip I'd said to Dave that I wanted to try and bike 100 miles, a century, at least one day of the trip. This day we woke up early and Dave made me put my bike where my mouth was. We split from the 101 again and followed the road inland through dairy country, then up into the mountains and onto Avenue of the Giants, which runs through Humboldt Redwoods State Park, and emerged, almost at sunset, at a park in Benbow, CA. Although I was definitely at my limit, we'd ridden 188.6 kilometers - 117.2 miles!Thursday, 28 June
After the long day, we took a shorter one, which was fortunate, since the route took us away from the 101 for good, and onto California Route 1, which wound up over the highest climb of the trip and back down to the coast. It was slow going, but it felt great to end the day in the little beach-access town of Cleone, where MacKerricher State Park is. Total distance: 99.5km (62.0mi).Friday, 29 June
A longer day through easy-riding country (rolling hills, farmland, and little coastal towns) took us to Salt Point State Park, an area of dwarfed conifer forest right on the coast. Four days after my blowout, my new tires still hadn't had a flat. Distance: 131.1km (81.5mi).Saturday, 30 June
And now we had only a short day's ride down the last stretch of coast before San Francisco. A quick 110.0km (68.4mi) took us through Bodega Bay and past Point Reyes National Seashore to Samuel P. Taylor State Park, in the distant suburbs of San Francisco.Sunday, 1 July
Journey's end, just about. A short morning ride of 54.8km (34.0mi) took us through the northern suburbs of San Francisco and over the Golden Gate Bridge. We made it to First Mennonite Church of San Francisco only by the end of the Sunday service, but in plenty of time to sing Old Number 606 as a benediction and join the welcoming congregation for a potluck fellowship meal. We spent the day seeing the city, and slept at the San Francisco MVS house.The next morning, I took the train to San Jose (Dave got up earlier to bike it), registered at the convention center, and attended my first delegate meeting in sweaty track pants and my only clean shirt, the San Jose 2007 t-shirt I got when I registered. My luggage arrived after the delegate session.
Which brings us to today, the first full day of the convention. It's just starting, and I need breakfast. More later!
Labels: biking, photo, San Jose 2007, summer, travel
01 July 2007
I'm in San Francisco!
Labels: biking, San Jose 2007, summer, travel
19 June 2007
Take only what you need ...
Bicycle touring forces you to adhere to the spirit, if not the letter, of Mark 6:8. Dave and I have to pedal everything we take uphill and down ourselves, so we've got to make sure we only take what we absolutely need. That means, until I get to San Jose and meet up with the luggage I'll send ahead with a contact from Portland, I've only got four t-shirts and two pairs of cycling shorts to wear, plus layers to thermoregulate if it's cool and a rain jacket/wind breaker. It means I'll trade in my Chacos and their oh-so-comfortable but oh-so-weighty footbeds for a lightweight pair of cheap flip-flops. It means I'll just take a Lexan spoon and some disposable plastic bowls for tableware. Actually, there's probably still somewhere I can cut weight. I leave at noon tomorrow. Gotta go!
Labels: biking, San Jose 2007, summer, travel
17 June 2007
Actions will be taken!
- 1-9: Front matter, including "Welcome from Jim Schrag" and Table of Contents
- 10-75: References, including information on Delegate Assembly procedures and philosophy, the MCUSA bylaws, financial reports, and an update on MCUSA's "Vision and Priorities"
- 78-106: Action and discussion items
- 116-138: Profiles of MCUSA area conferences
- 140-164: Profiles of MCUSA ministries and organizations
- 168-174: Profiles of MCUSA-affiliated schools
- 176-180: Profiles of MCUSA "constituency groups," like Mennonite Women USA and the African American Mennonite Association
- 182-189: Profiles of MCUSA boards, committees, councils, and ministry teams
- 192-204: Profiles of "other Mennonite groups" like Mennonite Camping Association, the Mennonite Central Committee, and the National Campaign for a Peace Tax Fund
Either way, I can see some significant omissions in the action/discussion items. In the workbook's list there are four items of business: nominations for various positions in MCUSA administration and ministries, a review of the denomination six years after its formation from the merger of the Old Mennonite Church and the General Conference Mennonite Church, a resolution voicing commitment to provide health care access to pastors serving all member congregations, and a decision on joining the ecumenical group Christian Churches Together. Those are all important points of action, but they don't add up to a very ambitious agenda. If I were to suggest priorities for the Delegate Assembly (and maybe I get to, being a delegate), I'd say there are two major points on which we could productively make public statements: the War on Terror, and poverty at both the global and domestic scale.
The War on Terror. As a historic peace church, MCUSA should obviously have something to say about the ongoing war in Iraq and Afghanistan; but I think we could productively speak to a broader issue. I'd suggest a resolution calling for (1) the treatment of terrorism as an issue for law enforcement (police) rather than the military, (2) adherence to the U.S. Constitution and international treaties in the pursuit, capture, and detention of suspected terrorists, and (3) ultimately solving the problem of terrorism by addressing underlying societal forces that create it, particularly poverty.
Poverty at home and abroad. San Jose 2007 attendees will be participating in a wide array of service projects while they're in town, but I think that, in keeping with Christ's mandate to care for "the least of these brothers of mine", we should renew our commitment to serve the poor in our nation and around the world, and maybe even suggest particular public policy decisions. For instance, domestic poverty might be addressed by improved access to health care for all Americans, and by an increase in the minimum wage. In reference to international poverty, we could call for an increase in U.S. foreign aid, which remains embarrassingly low.
These are just ideas off the top of my head. Maybe people are already working on similar (or better) resolutions ... I feel kind of out of the loop just now.
Labels: church, San Jose 2007
14 June 2007
Less than a week to go!
Saturday I drove up to the REIoutlet in Spokane and bought myself a rear rack and some panniers, the last equipment I needed to buy for the trip. Tomorrow I've an appointment at the local bike shop for a final pre-tour tuneup and inspection. And I'm keeping up with my training commitment, riding at least 100 miles a week. Over this weekend, I'll have a go at one last long ride of 50 miles or more. And I'll have to start thinking about packing.
Labels: biking, church, San Jose 2007, summer, travel
03 June 2007
The road to San Jose: wildlife and nonbinding statements
I'll be biking into San Jose (where I'll be serving as a congregational delegate representing Landisville) with Dave Landis, and I need training. So I spent much of today cycling on the Trail of the Coeur D'Alenes, a rails-to-trails route that runs almost across the Idaho panhandle, from Plummer to Mullan. It was hot today, but it was a beautiful ride, with lots of scenery and wildlife to take my mind off my aching legs.
Total, I rode about 47 miles; the goal was to make it from Plummer to Smelterville, which is a bit over 51 miles, but I had a spectacular blowout just before the Enaville trailhead (conveniently), and had to call my ride to come get me there, instead. I'd been warned I needed new tires pretty soon; looks like I'm getting them tomorrow.
I'm also starting on non-athletic preparations for the conference; Saturday's mail included my copy of the Delegate Assembly Workbook. Right inside the front cover is a copy of a last-minute addition - a nonbinding statement asking that Mennonite Church USA take action to "end the practice of disciplining or expelling congregations based on differing interpretations of the Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective. It's for "discussion only," as an attached note from the Executive Board says, but this is still a striking statement. Mennonite history could be cynically characterized as a long list of splitting events - could we come around to the idea that we should remain in communion with people who hold opposing views?
Labels: biking, church, San Jose 2007, summer, travel
08 February 2007
I know what I'm doing this summer
Labels: biking, church, San Jose 2007, summer, travel
All material on this site is the intellectual property of Jeremy B. Yoder unless otherwise indicated.











